It was shocking when the news broke about apple juice containing a high percentage of inorganic arsenic. But when headlines read “High levels of arsenic found in organic foods, baby formula” it makes your stomach drop. But wait it is organic! How does organic contain arsenic? Is it just organic brown rice syrup or does that mean that brown rice does as well? It may leave your head spinning and confused about what is safe for you to give your kids and what is safe for you.
While babies and toddlers little bodies are developing it puts them in a danger zone to be ingesting toxins. Which makes it horrifying to think that the organic baby formula on the shelves could be providing levels of arsenic that are higher then what is allowed in drinking water.
Dartmouth College released a study that tested 17 infant formulas, 22 cereal bars, and 3 energy shot drinks. Two of the formulas that contained organic brown rice syrup as a main ingredient tested 20 times higher than those that didn’t contain organic brown rice syrup. The soy-based formula tested at 21.4 ppb (parts per billion) and the dairy-based tested at 8.6 ppb. The regulation level for drinking water is 10 ppb.
Brown rice syrup is an alternative to high fructose corn syrup and is used in many organic foods as a sweetener. Brown rice syrup does come from brown rice. According to BrownRiceSyrups.com, the conventional process of making organic brown rice syrup is to ferment the brown rice with special enzymes that break apart the natural starches of the grain. Then they strain off the fermented liquid and continue cooking it to the desired consistency. Brown rice syrup also has a lot of beneficial health properties. It dissolves easily in our bloodstream which means it doesn’t have as much potential to build fat like sugar, it controls blood sugar levels and helps keep lower cholesterol levels. It is a complex carbohydrate and takes longer to breakdown which provides more energy which is why it is used in energy bars. But it is concentrated brown rice which creates the possibility to contain higher levels of arsenic then plain brown rice.
Rice products have been on the rise as wheat sensitivities have grown recently. On the Food Matters website they talk about being cautious when considering giving a child rice milk. Once again, concentration and quantity are important. A little one can consume a much larger quantity of rice product when drinking a cup of rice milk then when eating a serving of cooked brown rice, and therefore they are more likely to ingest higher levels of arsenic ingestion. If your child does have sensitivities to dairy and soy, the other alternative is almond milk. Where does that leave us? Is it safe to consume brown rice and does it matter if it is organic?
To answer these questions we have to understand where a lot of our rice comes from. Arsenic-lead pesticides weren’t completely banned until 2 years ago. They were used excessively in the south on the cotton fields and orchards. This is even more unfortunate since rice naturally soaks up arsenic from the soil. In fact the cotton fields were so contaminated when farmers first started growing rice that they couldn’t yield much crop. Therefore they bred a seed that would thrive in those kinds of conditions. According to the EHP (environmental health perspectives) website, we grow half of our rice in Arkansas and 20% of it comes from California. The rest is grown in Louisiana, Mississippi, Texas, Missouri, and Florida. In 2007 a professor from University of Aberdeen, Scotland found the rice grown in California contained 41% less arsenic than that grown in the south central US. So naturally, buying rice that is grown in California can reduce the levels of arsenic you ingest.
Being a mom and having to mission to feed babies the best, I found this information from Consumer Reports very troubling. Another study done by a man from Dartmouth released his findings in 2011 that he found 23 ppb levels of arsenic in brand name jars of baby food with 70-90% of that being inorganic arsenic. In the United Kingdom in 2008 published a study that showed levels of 60-120 ppb of inorganic arsenic in 20 ounce packets of dried rice cereal.
Brown Rice cereals have traditionally been introduced as babies’ first food because it is easy to digest. With all these studies on rice and the levels of arsenic and knowing the dangers of exposing a developing baby’s system to harsh toxins there are much more nutritious and safe first foods to feed your baby. Avocado is a wonderful first food! It can be mashed to the perfect consistency and provides heaps of nutrients. Banana, sweet potato, pears, squash, and green beans are also great first baby foods.
To sum it up, in the articles I have read the general consensus is that no one needs to stop eating brown rice. And that organic brown rice is less likely to have as high of arsenic levels as conventional rice due to the strict organic certification standards regulating allowable levels of arsenic in the soils in which the rice is grown.
As stated many times before it is not good to expose babies and young children to toxins, so it is best to avoid food made with concentrated brown rice products. The safest way to know what you and your family are ingesting is to avoid organic and conventional processed foods all together. There is something to be said about good old fashioned home cookin!
Here were the best resources I found. If you want to know more please check them out.
http://gma.yahoo.com/organic-brown-rice-syrup-hidden-arsenic-source-194615982–abc-news.html
http://www.enn.com/pollution/article/44007
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/02/16/organic-brown-rice-syrup-arsenic_n_1281675.html
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1892142/
http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/2012/01/arsenic-in-your-juice/index.htm














